Discipline X Games
scoring·30 min read

Teams of different sizes: total, average or participation-weighted score?

Three hypothetical teams of 4, 7 and 10 members show how total points favour large teams, plain averages favour small ones, and a participation measure widens the gaps without changing the order in this example.

By Discipline X Games Editorial Team·Published 2026-11-17

Real workplace challenges rarely have equal teams. A department of ten and a department of four cannot be compared by adding up points, because the bigger team starts with more bodies. This article puts three scoring options through one hypothetical example. The members’ weekly points below are made up for illustration; they are not data from any real challenge.

The example

Weekly points per member, listed from highest to lowest:

Team Members Points per member
Red 4 310, 280, 240, 150
Green 7 260, 240, 200, 180, 120, 60, 0
Blue 10 300, 260, 220, 180, 140, 100, 80, 60, 40, 0

Three team scores

  1. Total points. Add up every member’s points.
  2. Average per member. Total divided by headcount, including members who did nothing.
  3. Participation-weighted average. The average multiplied by the share of members who reached a minimum, set here at 60 points a week (a design choice, not a standard).
Team Total Average per member Share reaching 60 points Weighted average
Red 980 245.0 4 of 4 = 100.0% 245.0
Green 1,060 151.4 6 of 7 = 85.7% 129.8
Blue 1,380 138.0 8 of 10 = 80.0% 110.4

Totals rank Blue first, Green second, Red third. Both averages reverse that order: Red, Green, Blue. In this example the order does not differ between the plain and weighted averages, but the gap does: Blue’s weighted score is 110.4 against Red’s 245.0, because the weighting subtracts the effect of members who barely took part.

What each option rewards

  • Total rewards recruiting. If a team can add a member, its score can only go up. That may be the point of a challenge about participation, but not of one about activity.
  • Average rewards a small, committed team and is hurt by one inactive member much more in a team of four than in a team of ten. In Blue, the member with zero points pulls the average from 153.3 (1,380 / 9) down to 138.0 (1,380 / 10), a drop of 15.3 points. If members contributed equally, one inactive member would remove 25% of a four-person team’s average (3 of 4 members contributing) but 10% of a ten-person team’s (9 of 10).
  • Participation-weighted pushes teams to bring everybody to a modest level, which is the goal in a workplace challenge for beginners. Its minimum is arbitrary, so publish it with the rules.

A practical recommendation

Choose the rule from the goal and say so in the rules page:

  • Goal is wide participation: weighted average, with a low minimum.
  • Goal is total activity across a fixed group, such as one office: total.
  • Teams are of similar size: the plain average is simplest.

Whichever you pick, run the example above with your own numbers before you open registration. If the winner changes when you switch rules, tell participants why you chose yours. For weekly minimums you might use the 150 minutes of moderate activity per week the CDC gives for adults as a reference point, remembering that the CDC figure is a health recommendation and not a scoring standard.

Sources


Sources

AI assistance recorded as: AI draft, not edited